RES10304
Release Date: July 2022
Mary Bevan (soprano)
Catherine Carby (mezzo-soprano)
Mark Wilde (tenor)
John Savournin (bass-baritone)
The Brook Street Band
John Andrews (conductor)
Thomas Arne’s opera The Judgment of Paris (1742), a setting of William Congreve’s libretto of the same name, is known only from the printed score, but in this world premiere recording is performed with panache and authority by The Brook Street Band and a scintillating young cast led by sopranos Mary Bevan (Venus), Susanna Fairbairn (Pallas) and Gillian Ramm (Juno), with tenors Ed Lyon as the shepherd Paris and Anthony Gregory as Mercury, all under the expert direction of conductor John Andrews.
By the end of the opera we are not surprised when Venus’s softly, softly appeal to her shepherd judge succeeds over the more demonstrative blandishments of her competitors, Pallas and Juno.
This is a lovely discovery, with all the cast joining in the spirit of this fable to give it a stylish and compelling revival.
(Dutton Vocalion)
1 | I. Overture |
2 | II. First and Second Tune |
3 | Act I: III. Fly, Neighbours, fly, The Dragon’s nigh |
4 | Act I: IV. The Dragon’s March crossing the stage |
5 | Act I: V. What wretched Havock does this Dragon make! |
6 | Act I: VI. Poor Children three Devoured he |
7 | Act I: VII. Houses and Churches, To Him are Geese and Turkies |
8 | Act I: VIII. O Father! |
9 | Act I: IX. But to hear the Children mutter |
10 | Act I: X. This Dragon very modish |
11 | Act I: XI. He’s a Man ev’ry Inch, I assure you |
12 | Act I: XII. Let’s go to his Dwelling |
13 | Act I: XIII. Symphony |
14 | Act I: XIV. Come, Friends, let’s circulate the cheerful Glass |
15 | Act I: XV. Zeno, Plato, Aristotle |
16 | Act I: XVI. O save us all! Moore of Moore Hall! |
17 | Act I: XVII. Gentle Knight! all Knights exceeding |
18 | Act I: XVIII. Her looks shoot thro’ my Soul |
19 | Act I: XIX. If that’s all you ask |
20 | Act I: XX. A forward Lady! |
21 | Act I: XXI. Let my Dearest be near me |
22 | Act I: XXII. O Villain! Monster! Devil! |
23 | Act I: XXIII. No Place shall conceal ‘em |
24 | Act I: XXIV. By Jove! I’m blown |
25 | Act I: XXV. By the Beer, as brown as Berry |
26 | Act I: XXVI. But do you really love me |
27 | Act I: XXVII. Pigs shall not be So fond as we |
28 | Act II: XXVIII. Sure my Stays will burst with sobbing |
29 | Act II: XXIX. My Madge! My HoneySuckle, in the Dumps! |
30 | Act II: XXX. Insulting Gipsey, You’re surely tipsy |
31 | Act II: XXXI. Lauk! what a monstrous Tail our Cat has got |
32 | Act II: XXXII. O give me not up |
33 | Act II: XXXIII. Come, come, forgive her! |
34 | Act II: XXXIV. Oh how easy is a woman |
35 | Act II: XXXV. Now, now, or never save us, valiant Moore! |
36 | Act II: XXXVI. Fill the mighty flagon |
37 | Act III: XXXVII. One Buss, dear Margery |
38 | Act III: XXXVIII. Dragon! thus I dare thee – It is not Strength that always wins |
39 | Act III: XXXIX. Symphony – What nasty Dog has got into the Well |
40 | Act III: XL. Oh ho! Master Moore, You Son of a Whore |
41 | Act III: XLI. Battle Piece |
42 | Act III: XLII. Oh! The Devil take your Toe |
43 | Act III: XLIII. Oh, my Champion! how d’ye do |
44 | Act III: XLIV. My sweet Honeysuckle |
45 | Act III: XLV. Most mighty Moore |
46 | Act III: XLVI. Sing, sing, and rorio, An Oratorio |
“It’s full of lively dances and arias and a few noisy, lip-smacking kisses…it fills a gap for students of the 18th-century English stage, but the commitment of these performers creates its own, wider pleasure.”
Fiona Maddocks, The Guardian
“Performed with zest and just the right blend of seriousness and farcical humour.”
BBC Radio 3 Record Review
“This uproarious send-up of Handelian operatic conventions (transposed to a Yorkshire village and complete with earthy local colloquialisms) works so well because both composer and cast demonstrate are so fully in command of the style that’s being satirised; Bevan and Carby have a riot with the coloratura cat-fight ‘Insulting gypsy, you’re surely tipsy’, whilst Wilde delivers the cod-heroics of ‘Dragon, to atoms I’ll tear thee’ (shades of Acis’s ‘Love sounds the alarm’ here) with just the right amount of tongue-in-cheek braggadocio.”
Presto Music Editor’s Choice
“The cast are all excellent, singing the music with wonderfully po-faced glee and plenty of Handelian style. There is no hint of send-up, and of course that is what makes it so much fun. The singers, instrumentalists and conductor are all able to well hold their own in genuine opera seria, and this stylistic confidence shines through here.”
Planet Hugill 4.5 stars
“In this premiere recording, conductor John Andrews shrewdly reserves buffoonery for Carey and Lampe’s antic scenes, heightening the galant elements of duets and ensembles, and giving performers space for arresting explorations of Lampe’s lyricism. In the showpiece ‘Gentle Knight’, soprano Mary Bevan gently wraps stunning ascending embellishments around the oboe’s melody. In the big lament aria, cellist Tatty Theo enriches the subtle articulation and rich timbres of mezzo-soprano Catherine Carby with her own. By contrast, tenor Mark Wilde as the knight and bass-baritone John Savournin as a squire and the dragon have great fun with the work’s excesses, Wilde prefacing his runs with vulgar gulps and Savournin growling absurdly.”
BBC Music Magazine, Opera and Editor’s Choice, 5 *s
“What a surprise! This comic opera, popular in its day, has been languishing as a passing reference in the history books. Now it has been brought to life in this excellent performance by The Brook Street Band under John Andrews.”
Gramophone Magazine, Editor’s Choice
“With sunny support from the brilliant Brook Street Band and John Andrews’s insouciant direction, this is a Dragon’s dish to savour”
Opera Magazine